Community Forum
Suggestions & improvements Seperation between finalized Redesigns and ones that need feedback.
Seperation between finalized Redesigns and ones that need feedback.
Topic
Joined 3 years ago
Earned 1550 RDMs
Rank #72 Lecros wrote:
2 years ago
If you seperate them then people like me who need feedback first can post it in a seperate section. Of course companies should look at the ideas in the test fase too and could reward them if they want. But this would make everything look more professional and give it a bigger sense of structure. For example the Logo challenges from the times before Drostoff joined us, had lots of people posting like 7 different versions of their redesigns and it would be a lot better if we only saw the finalized ones. When you click a challenge you can pick between All, Finalized and in Progress to sort the Ideas and the different types of Ideas should also have a different color (Finalized being darker then the In Progress ones) This way we also won't have more people like Drostoff who get extremely irritated by the people that don't expand on their ideas too much and we know who to give feedback too. Also this way I could have a place to try out the ideas im not exactly sure off :p. You could put the two categories in peoples personalized settings so they auto enter a category. And when uploading a redesign you should check a checkbox to signify your coice :p. I really hope you read this Maxim ^^
Joined 2 years ago
Earned 2000 RDMs
Rank #58 claus wrote:
2 years ago
I madly support this suggestion, lecros! It would be great if people could view these: 'alles', 'afgewerkt', 'WiP' en 'beloond' / 'all', 'finished', 'WiP' and 'rewarded'. WiP stands for Work in Progress
Joined 3 years ago
Earned 1550 RDMs
Rank #72 Lecros wrote:
2 years ago
Thank you for your comment. I have now had input from 4 tottally different types of redesigners so I really think this could be a good addition to the site :p. Adding the rewarded we already had is a good idea ^^. (Or actually you added your idea of fusing it with the current site which I hadnt completely thought out yet.)
Joined 2 years ago
Earned 1400 RDMs
Rank #82 Erwtj3 wrote:
2 years ago
I think it's a good idea as well. Sometimes you just don't want to spend hours making a vector-logo when your idea is cr*p. ;) So if we can upload some hand drawn scetches or basic ideas we'll know which of these we have to improve.
Joined 3 years ago Maxim from Redesignme wrote:
2 years ago
Hi guys, Thanks for your suggestions. I'll discuss this with the development team next week! Cheers, Maxim
Joined 2 years ago
Earned 2900 RDMs
Rank #46 Drostof wrote:
2 years ago
I'm a big fan of it! But some of us think they have an end-result while others still consider it work in progress. Where do you draw the line. Or should there be a possibility to shift designs between WiP and Final (so administrators can move them if "the crowd" is not satisfied yet)?
Joined 2 years ago
Earned 1400 RDMs
Rank #82 Erwtj3 wrote:
2 years ago
Perhaps the administrator of the challenge can give a grade in which he or she thinks the design is finalised. E.g. : 1/5: just the idea 2/5: basic hand drawn sketches 3/5: hand drawn sketch is optimalised 4/5: logo is drawn as a vector image, but needs some finishing touches 5/5: design is finished That way you can list them in order of finalisation score.
Joined 3 years ago
Earned 1550 RDMs
Rank #72 Lecros wrote:
2 years ago
Door simpele feedback kun je zegegn van. Leuk idee maar volgens mij hoort dit in WiP en dan kan je daar tegen in gaan als je het oneens bent. En dan kun je het zelf verplaatsen tussen de 2 sectoren. Misschien dat je oude commentaar ook weggesorteerd kan worden naar een andere pagina ofzoow zodat het vers kan beginnen met je eindresultaat. Hierdoor krijg je ook minder hard commentaar als je bijvoorbeeld minder goed ben met logos en kun je gewoon een hooop experimenteren. En dat lijkt me op den lange duur erg handig ^^
Powered by
© 2007-2012 Redesignme B.V.